The Origin of Consciousness in the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind
Julian Jaynes' book, "The Origin of Consciousness in the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind," presents a revolutionary theory about the evolution of human consciousness. Jaynes proposes that until around 3,000 years ago, human beings did not possess what we would recognize as self-aware, introspective consciousness. Instead, they operated under a "bicameral" mind, where the two brain hemispheres were functionally separate. In this pre-conscious state, individuals experienced auditory hallucinations which they interpreted as the voices of gods or ancestors guiding their actions. This explains the prevalence of divine voices in ancient literature and mythologies, where gods directly communicate with humans, like in the Iliad where characters hear the gods' commands during battle.
Jaynes suggests that these hallucinations were particularly vivid for figures who would later be considered mystics, sages, or prophets. These individuals, due to their roles or societal functions, were more open to or reliant on these divine voices for guidance. For instance, the prophets of the Old Testament or the oracles of ancient Greece might have been individuals whose bicameral minds were exceptionally active, providing them with what we might interpret as divine inspiration or revelation. Jaynes argues that these experiences were not just metaphorical or spiritual but were literal auditory phenomena, interpreted through the cultural lens of the time as direct communications from deities.
The transition from this bicameral mind to the modern, conscious mind, according to Jaynes, was triggered by various societal and cultural changes, including the complexity of civilizations, the need for more complex decision-making, and the increasing literacy which fostered introspection. This shift led to the breakdown of the bicameral mind, where the voices were no longer heard as external commands but began to be internalized as thoughts or conscience. However, Jaynes posits that remnants of this bicameral experience linger in modern phenomena like schizophrenia, where individuals might hear voices, or in the spiritual and religious experiences where people interpret inner voices as divine guidance, suggesting a continuity with our bicameral past.
When Julian Jaynes first published "The Origin of Consciousness in the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind" in 1976, his theories were met with a mix of fascination and skepticism. While some scholars and psychologists were intrigued by his novel interpretation of historical consciousness, many in the academic community dismissed it as speculative or lacking empirical support. The idea that human consciousness evolved from an auditory hallucinatory state was seen as radical and not easily reconcilable with existing psychological models. Today, Jaynes' theories are not widely accepted in mainstream psychology or neuroscience, but they have gained a sort of cult following and are frequently cited in discussions about the nature of consciousness, particularly in interdisciplinary fields like cognitive archaeology, philosophy of mind, and even some literary theory. His work is now seen more as an intriguing hypothesis that prompts further research into the origins and nature of consciousness, rather than a definitive scientific theory, and it continues to spark debates and inspire research into human cognition and historical psychology.
For mystics today, Jaynes' theory implies that their mystical experiences could be seen as echoes of this bicameral state. These individuals might be particularly sensitive to or capable of accessing a state where the brain's left and right hemispheres communicate in ways reminiscent of ancient times. This could explain why some modern spiritual practices aim to quiet the conscious mind to hear a 'higher' or 'inner' voice, potentially tapping into what was once a more common human experience. Jaynes' theory thus provides a provocative framework for understanding the psychological basis of religious and mystical experiences, suggesting they are not merely cultural constructs but have a deep-seated, evolutionary origin.
The Origin of Consciousness in the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind is still in print and available on Amazon.
Note that I might make a small commission if you purchase the book through this link.
